📖 Tutorial S Substack

Substack Workflow — A Step-by-Step Tutorial

Launch a paid newsletter on Substack, set up free and paid tiers, publish your first post, and grow from 0 to your first 100 paid subscribers.

45 min
Est. Time
Beginner
Difficulty
10% of paid revenue
Cost
CreatorStack Team
Author

Substack Workflow — A Step-by-Step Tutorial

Substack lets you publish a newsletter, charge for it, and own your audience — no algorithm, no feed competition, no platform dictating your reach. This tutorial walks you through launching a publication, configuring paid tiers, writing your first post, and setting up the growth mechanics to reach your first 100 paid subscribers.

Step 1: Create Your Publication

  1. Go to substack.com → click Start Writing
  2. Sign up with your email (or Google account)
  3. Set your publication name — this becomes your brand. Pick something specific: “The AI Engineering Weekly” beats “John’s Newsletter” every time.
  4. Choose your URL: yourname.substack.com (free) or connect a custom domain ($50 one-time, highly recommended for branding)
  5. Write a one-sentence tagline (appears in your header and in Substack’s discovery feed)
  6. Upload a logo (square, at least 256×256px) — this appears on your Substack page and in every email
  7. Pick a theme color — it carries through to buttons, links, and accent elements in your emails

Pro tip: Your tagline should answer one question: “What will I get if I subscribe?” Not “Thoughts on technology and the future” (vague). Instead: “One actionable AI workflow every Tuesday, tested before I write about it.” Specificity converts.

Step 2: Configure Your Email Settings

Substack sends your posts directly to subscribers’ inboxes. Get this right before publishing anything:

  1. Go to Settings → Email
  2. Set your From name — use your publication name, not your personal name (unless you ARE the brand)
  3. Set Reply-to address — use a real email you check. Reader replies are where engagement starts.
  4. Go to Settings → Publication Settings
  5. Set your publication type: Newsletter, Podcast, or Video (you can add podcast/video later)
  6. Enable Substack Chat — this gives subscribers a private chat thread (like a Discord channel, but native to Substack)

Pro tip: Test your email deliverability before launching. Send a test post to yourself and check if it lands in the inbox or spam folder. If it hits spam, you may need to verify your domain’s SPF/DKIM records (Substack provides instructions if you use a custom domain).

Step 3: Set Up Paid Tiers

This is where Substack differentiates from free newsletters. You control the pricing:

  1. Go to Settings → Payments
  2. Connect to Stripe (Substack uses Stripe Connect — funds go directly to your bank account)
  3. Enable Paid subscriptions
  4. Set your monthly price: Substack defaults to $5/month and $50/year. You can adjust:
    • $5/month: Standard for most newsletters. Low friction, high volume.
    • $8-10/month: For niche, high-value content (financial analysis, industry intel). Fewer subscribers but higher revenue per reader.
    • $15+/month: Only if you’re an established expert with unique access. Risky for new publications.
  5. Set a founding member tier ($150-500/year) — super fans who want to support you above the standard price. Include a perk: direct access, Q&A sessions, or a private call.
  6. Set your free vs paid split. Recommended starting structure:
    • Free: Every post — full content, no paywall. Build audience first.
    • After 3 months: Switch to a free/paid mix — free posts get truncated with a “Subscribe to read more” prompt.

Substack’s revenue model: Substack takes 10% of paid subscription revenue. Stripe takes ~3% for payment processing. You keep 87%. Compare to YouTube (takes 45% of ad revenue) or Patreon (8-12% + payment fees).

Pro tip: Don’t launch with a paywall on day one. You need readers before you can charge them. Publish 8-12 free posts to build trust and demonstrate value. When readers start asking “how do I support you?”, that’s when you introduce paid tiers.

Step 4: Write and Publish Your First Post

  1. Click Posts → New Post
  2. Write your headline — keep it under 60 characters (email subject lines truncate after that)
  3. Write your post in the Substack editor (supports rich text, images, embeds):
    • Start with a hook (1-2 sentences that make the reader want to continue)
    • Use short paragraphs (2-3 sentences max — email reading is skimming)
    • Add images every 300-500 words to break up text
    • Embed relevant content: tweets, YouTube videos, charts (Substack auto-embeds most URLs)
  4. Set your post settings:
    • Audience: Everyone (free) or Paid subscribers only
    • Subtitle: Optional, appears under the headline in emails
    • Preview: The first few sentences readers see before “Continue reading”
  5. Click Publish
  6. Choose: Send to all subscribers now or Schedule for later

Pro tip: Schedule posts for the same day and time each week. Substack readers are creatures of habit — if they expect your newsletter every Tuesday at 8am, they’ll open it. Inconsistent publishing schedules kill open rates. Pick a day, commit to it for 12 weeks minimum.

Step 5: Set Up Your Growth Funnel

Substack doesn’t promote your newsletter for you. You need external traffic:

  1. Import existing email list: Go to Settings → Import → upload a CSV of existing subscribers. Substack sends them a confirmation email (required by anti-spam law). Only confirmed emails become Substack subscribers.

  2. Add a subscribe link everywhere:

    • Social media bios (Twitter/X, LinkedIn, Instagram)
    • YouTube video descriptions
    • Email signature
    • Personal website or blog
    • The URL format: yourname.substack.com/subscribe
  3. Enable Substack Recommendations: Go to Settings → Recommendations. When someone subscribes to your publication, Substack shows them 3 other newsletters to subscribe to. Other publications recommend you in return. This is Substack’s biggest growth engine — it drives 40%+ of new subscriptions for established publications.

  4. Write a welcome email: Go to Settings → Welcome Email. This auto-sends to every new subscriber. Include:

    • What to expect (topic, frequency, format)
    • Links to your 3 best posts (so new readers immediately get value)
    • A personal note (why you started this, what drives you)

Pro tip: The Substack Recommendations network is the single most effective growth tool on the platform. To get recommended by other publications, you need to recommend them first. Find 3-5 complementary newsletters in your niche, set them as your recommendations, then email the authors introducing yourself and asking to cross-recommend. Most will say yes — it’s mutually beneficial.

Step 6: Track Growth and Revenue

  1. Go to Dashboard to see:
    • Total subscribers: Free + paid
    • Paid subscribers: Your revenue source
    • Monthly recurring revenue (MRR): Paid subscribers × their monthly rate
    • Churn rate: Percentage of paid subscribers who cancel each month
    • Open rate: What percentage of subscribers open your emails (industry average: 30-40%)
  2. Go to Subscribers tab to see individual subscriber data: when they joined, whether they’re free or paid, their email engagement history
  3. Go to Revenue tab to see: gross revenue, Substack’s 10% cut, Stripe fees, and your net payout

Key milestones to track:

  • 100 free subscribers: You’ve found an audience. Keep publishing.
  • 1,000 free subscribers: Time to introduce paid tiers if you haven’t.
  • 100 paid subscribers: At $5/mo, that’s $435/mo net (after Substack + Stripe fees). You have a business.
  • 1,000 paid subscribers: $4,350/mo net. Full-time income for most people.

Pro tip: Watch your open rate closely. If it drops below 25%, you’re either publishing too frequently (subscribers are tired), your headlines are weak, or your content quality has slipped. A declining open rate precedes a declining paid subscriber count by 2-3 months — fix it before it hits revenue.

Recap

You created a publication, configured email deliverability, set up Stripe-backed paid tiers, published your first post, built a growth funnel with Substack Recommendations, and learned to track the metrics that predict revenue. Substack’s model is simple: write valuable content consistently, convert free readers to paid, and Substack handles the payments, email delivery, and subscriber management. Your only job is to be worth paying for.